22 May 2021, 06:51 | #21 | ||
Engineer
Join Date: Oct 2018
Location: Shadow realm
Posts: 167
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
||
22 May 2021, 08:42 | #22 |
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2019
Location: Greece
Posts: 992
|
I have been trying to find this legendary input lag for months, playing games (incl. Pinball Dreams) almost side by side on my A500 and my Pi4 to see if anything there would justify my obtaining a Mister.
Guess what? No difference. I also do not doubt that there "should be" input lag issues, but I cannot for the life of me feel any. There are a lot of real things that cannot be perceived by humans (eg sound frequencies) above or below a certain threshold, so I guess some people are more sensitive to this legendary 'lag' than others (I don't know if there are any studies on input lag perception). Or have a very laggy monitor/controller setup. Or, more probably, they perceive what they expect that they should perceive. |
22 May 2021, 09:01 | #23 | |
Engineer
Join Date: Oct 2018
Location: Shadow realm
Posts: 167
|
Quote:
Why would anyone want to settle for mediocrity? |
|
22 May 2021, 09:48 | #24 | |
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2019
Location: Greece
Posts: 992
|
Quote:
If both the Pi4 and the Mister provide with such a superb Amiga experience and the Pi4 is so much cheaper and easier to use, I feel we have a clear winner. Do not think I dislike the Mister, on the contrary, I just don't find much there to justify its purchase (aside from building a delicious setup like Novacoder's...yum!). I do not doubt that this lag exists and certainly do not doubt your experience. But I cannot for the life of me reproduce/feel it. If there was any adjusting involved, don't you think I would feel the difference when playing the same game back to back on Pi4 and A500? Especially with games like kick off 2, even a suspicion of laggy controls would have killed the experience instantly. Are you sure your setup (monitor/controller) does not cause this lag? |
|
22 May 2021, 09:56 | #25 | |
Engineer
Join Date: Oct 2018
Location: Shadow realm
Posts: 167
|
Quote:
Whereas. in contrast, Pi4 It is just a weaker computer than most people's primary desktop/workstation computer. These can run WinUAE, which is currently the best emulator. Whatever available for Pi4 simply isn't anywhere as good. It saddens me when people who have no FPGAs at all do instead buy these flavor-of-the-week SBCs. It's even sadder when they use them to do things their workstations do better. Advising against is about all I can do; ultimately it's not up to me. Last edited by admiral; 22 May 2021 at 10:01. Reason: better writing |
|
22 May 2021, 10:22 | #26 | |
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2019
Location: Greece
Posts: 992
|
Quote:
And, please, don't assume things about my experience with FPGA technology. |
|
22 May 2021, 10:35 | #27 |
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2016
Location: London
Posts: 345
|
You can try lagless vsync mode in WinUAE to reduce lag to very low levels. Has anyone directly compared miSTer vs WinUAE lagless vsync?
|
22 May 2021, 10:41 | #28 | |
Engineer
Join Date: Oct 2018
Location: Shadow realm
Posts: 167
|
Quote:
I'm glad about any progress on the latency front, and still doubtful whatever port rpi4 runs is up to scratch. It's been a while since I tried that, but it couldn't really manage to emulate an accurate AGA machine at realtime. |
|
22 May 2021, 11:59 | #29 | |
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2021
Location: UK
Posts: 66
|
Quote:
Along with the Mister FPGA, I bought a Pi4 for comparison and I really can't tell the difference. I would forget which one I was currently using. I guess I am just not sensitive to it. However, I prefer the Mister FPGA experience - the quicker boot, the simpler menus. I just find it generally simpler to use and more streamlined experience. Is that worth the difference in price? No probably not for me personally but it's bought now so I'm not going to worry about it. I have other plans for the Pi4 anyway. The one area of the Mister's "accuracy" that is starting to wear thin on me though is for some of the other cores other than the Amiga. Nostalgia of some of those systems (Spectrum, CPC and Vic20 for example) is great but having to go through the accurate process of remembering how to load them (e.g on CPC inserting the disk, typing CAT to see the disk contents then RUN"filename on the correct file but then a different process on a different system) gets a bit tedious for me compared to just using RetroPie and selecting a game. So on the one hand I love accuracy of it and on the other I don't Don't get me wrong though. The Mister is an incredible piece of kit and I prefer it over the Pi. |
|
22 May 2021, 12:42 | #30 |
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2019
Location: Greece
Posts: 992
|
@Fuzzball
Some legit points there, mate. I would disagree only on the simplicity of use point, since I haven't found yet a more easy, out-of-the-box, intuitive interface than Amiberry. Especially the option of just putting the unextracted .lha files in the roms folder and...boom, everything works, absolute WHDLoad goodness! |
22 May 2021, 12:51 | #31 |
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2021
Location: UK
Posts: 66
|
I never got round to trying Amiberry to be fair. I only tried RetroPie and piMiga 1.5. I had planned on trying Amiberry and starting from scratch but as I have the Mister anyway I didn't get round to it. I'm sure I will at some point.
One issue I have with the Mister is longevity. How long will the DE10 boards be produced for example? What happens if they become hard to source and mine packs in? What about if Intel stop subsidizing the cost of those boards and the price rockets? (it's hardly cheap now when it is being subsidized). In comparison, the Pi has been around a long time and you would expect new versions to keep coming for a long time. They are also a lot cheaper so easier to replace. The Pi feels the better long term investment but only time will tell on that one. |
22 May 2021, 13:09 | #32 |
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2019
Location: Greece
Posts: 992
|
@Fuzzball
If you are using RetroPie for Amiga emulation, chances are you are already using Amiberry. If not, you should try it. I have setup my Pi to boot up straight into RetroPie and Amiberry, so I have all the Amiga goodness straight away. Let's hope both projects continue for a long time, providing us with cool options for Amiga enjoyment. |
22 May 2021, 13:24 | #33 | |
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2021
Location: UK
Posts: 66
|
Quote:
|
|
22 May 2021, 13:30 | #34 | |
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2019
Location: Greece
Posts: 992
|
Quote:
Been hearing good things about MegaAGS as well on YT vids, so it sounds like a great option for Mister users. We are definitely spoilt for choice! |
|
22 May 2021, 13:49 | #35 |
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2015
Location: The Netherlands
Posts: 3,436
|
Input lag is difficult to rate because everyone has a different level of tolerance for it. Some people note it at 1 frame, others not until it's closer to as much as 10 (with most somewhere in between). Lagless emulation and/or a variable sync rate monitor can help a lot here.
Actually, the same kind of goes for the whole topic of accuracy, it's really personal and a bit more subjective than we might want to admit. For instance, I still to this day don't like emulation/FPGA simulation without scanlines enabled because removing them just looks wrong to me. Other despise scanlines. Some want to go all the way and have the emulation do everything period accurate. Others don't have patience for that. Etc, etc. To me it seems there's no one-size-fits-all approach here. Pick what best suits you and your budget. All the options out there can give very good results |
22 May 2021, 14:04 | #36 | |
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2019
Location: Ur, Atlantis
Posts: 2,042
|
Quote:
Pi4 is no doubt much cheaper, has a nice menu frontend, and also emulation perks, such as savestates. So if these things are important to an user, then it's a better choice. The downside is general sluggishness of the whole thing: the Retropie/Amiberry load times and menus in general. The in-game lag can be another factor, although I agree that its importance is vastly exaggerated because it's rather hard to detect. Other thing is that configuring the whole thing can be a nightmare....Retropie is full of little gotchas which you need to spend time finding how to solve and that can be annoying. MiSTer's advantages are a bit harder to explain. The lack of lag is definitely a thing, but as said above it might not be that important. The other is the fact that the devs are trying to actually replicate/simulate/whatever the chip logic as close to 1:1 as possible, so you can imagine it's actually the real machine. It contributes to that general "feel", along with the superfast boot and load times, general responsiveness, simple menus, and the fact you have to use it as you would the real thing. It really does work, but is definitely an "in your head" thing , so it's hard to argue about. Some people might care about it, some don't, or will get this kick from emulators anyway. So it's just different strokes, really. Pi4 is more of a mass-market solution (not a bad thing) while MiSTer, with its rather peculiar strong points, might appeal to a more niche enthusiast group, with specific needs. For example the main reason I use it is because it works so perfectly with CRTs, the other things are just a bonus. If not for that, I wouldn't be using it but also not a Pi - I'd stick with my powerful desktop which can run advanced shaders. And, I must admit I was disappointed with @admiral's "arguments" in this thread...unfortunately this is the kind of FPGA zealotry which most likely actually pushes people away, because of its elitist approach. EDIT: you can use MegaAGS in Winuae too. It's a good collection, but forces a lot of games into NTSC by default so the results can be a bit curious. @roondar: I don't like emualtion without scanlines AND shadowmask |
|
22 May 2021, 14:11 | #37 |
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2021
Location: UK
Posts: 66
|
Yes I'm a scanlines enabler too. It just too looks too "clean" otherwise.
I suspect not noticing the difference in lag between the Mister and Pi is down to the much bigger lag in my reaction times these days which are nowhere near what they used to be Last edited by Fuzzball; 22 May 2021 at 14:19. |
22 May 2021, 14:31 | #38 |
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2019
Location: Greece
Posts: 992
|
@roondar & dreadnought
Some great, level-headed posts there, gentlemen, as usual. @dreadnought Could we agree on the definition of superb Amiga experience as: being identical to the machine being emulated and hassle-free? This definition includes the shaders argument! :P I had Retropie problems on the controller front (and, from what I read here, other people as well had similar problems). It became a nightmare after a while, but I somehow managed to make it work, after some headache. Other than that, I had no problems at all. Is there a source for that? |
22 May 2021, 14:38 | #39 |
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2015
Location: The Netherlands
Posts: 3,436
|
Ah, nope, sorry
This is just my personal experience. I've seen people pretty much oblivious to it and I've seen people who are extremely sensitive to it. Reading it back, I do notice it looks more authoritative than it really was. Sorry, if that wasn't clear. |
22 May 2021, 14:56 | #40 |
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2019
Location: Greece
Posts: 992
|
No problem, mate, I would have just loved to read some proper studies on this interesting issue.
|
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
Thread Tools | |
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
My experience with the Amiga and music. | Lektroid | Nostalgia & memories | 13 | 04 September 2020 13:23 |
Amiga Emulation experience on various systems | antiriad76 | New to Emulation or Amiga scene | 8 | 31 October 2017 19:41 |
The Fractal Define r4 amiga tower experience | voyager | Hardware mods | 24 | 02 January 2017 02:25 |
What was your most memorable experience with Amiga? | diablothe2nd | Nostalgia & memories | 52 | 21 February 2013 21:49 |
The closest you'll get to a modern day Amiga experience | Galaxy | Retrogaming General Discussion | 8 | 15 June 2008 20:31 |
|
|