29 June 2024, 00:30 | #21 |
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2023
Location: Venus
Posts: 179
|
The A1200 sound output is far louder than the A500
so you will get better audio quality |
29 June 2024, 05:59 | #22 | |||
AKA Mr. Rhythm Master/AIS
Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: London, UK
Posts: 106
|
Quote:
Quote:
A very sensitive bat. Quote:
For decades now, there has been an ongoing debate amongst C64 aficionados as to which revision of SID sounds "best". What's very important to understand (aside from "best" being subjective) is that SID, unlike Paula, generated its tones internally, and due to the nature of chip manufacturing processes, literally no two SID wafers - even of the same revision - were likely to sound exactly alike, if one were to go deep enough into that rabbit hole. Paula does not generate her own tones - she literally takes data from Chip RAM, is able to process that data through many functions that are useful in terms of audio and musical reproduction, and feeds the processed data to a DAC setup which converts the signals to an analogue audio signal pumped out of the stereo phono sockets. The only part of that system that might affect the final output is the character of the DACs - and the whole point of a DAC is that they're supposed to be generic and predictable. Case in point - the Sega Mega Drive/Genesis used a YM2612 FM sound chip which in basic terms is a 6-channel version of the 8-channel YM2151 used on Sega's 1980s arcade games. However, the YM2612 was designed to be a low-cost component and - unlike the YM2151 which required an external DAC - had a basic DAC on the chip die itself, which is why FM music on a real Mega Drive tends to sound somewhat tinny compared to the arcade equivalent (a shortcoming that no longer exists as far as emulators are concerned). Back in 1991 I rescued my family's old Marantz hi-fi amp and speakers from the garage, set it up in my bedroom and hooked it up to my A500 (which made everything sound *epic* for that time... ). Two years later when I got my A1200 for Christmas, I naturally swapped it out and could perceive zero audible difference. Many years later when I started trying to get my head around audio engineering and music production, I went full-nerd and spent a day comparing the output from my "real" A1200 to that of the modern emulators, and observed that the analogue output from the A1200 had a very slight, but (just about) perceptible bias towards the low-end and mid-range - meaning that OG Paula + DAC has slightly more low-end "oomph" and mid "presence" compared to the raw dump from WinUAE. So what does that mean? In all honesty, not all that much. The likelihood of any noticeable variance in audio clarity between different iterations of Amiga hardware is beyond negligible. If your intent is to stick your Amiga's audio output through a hi-fi for a more immersive experience it doesn't matter in the slightest which model you use, and if your intent is to capture Amiga audio output to use in your own musical productions, chances are you're going to run it through EQ settings tailored to your own tastes anyway, so the same applies. Last edited by TuRRIcaNEd; 29 June 2024 at 06:05. |
|||
29 June 2024, 06:18 | #23 |
HOL/FTP busy bee
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Germany
Age: 46
Posts: 32,024
|
|
29 June 2024, 06:34 | #24 |
AKA Mr. Rhythm Master/AIS
Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: London, UK
Posts: 106
|
Back in the day (we're talking about 1997-ish), having reluctantly switched to Wintel for Uni, I had a feeling that the output of Fellow/WinUAE sounded a bit "flat" compared to the real thing - but I had no idea how to express it or understand why that might be. This is why I did a nerdy A/B test many years later.
|
29 June 2024, 06:49 | #25 |
Moderator
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 3,396
|
Sound chip in the Vampire V4 is quite advanced and it blows Paula away.
|
29 June 2024, 06:55 | #26 | |
AKA Mr. Rhythm Master/AIS
Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: London, UK
Posts: 106
|
Quote:
Anyways, as far as I can tell that wasn't the aim of the original question, which seemed to be whether any of the "classic" Amiga models had inherently superior audio fidelity despite every single one of them using Paula. |
|
29 June 2024, 09:35 | #27 | ||
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: PL?
Posts: 2,888
|
Quote:
Quote:
Seem CD32 was designed around same Paula as A600 but overall audio signal path is simply better. So despite Paula didn't changed (we know that this is untrue as mentioned earlier) since 1984/85 there are differences sometimes more important, sometimes less so you can have Amiga that has higher audio quality. In half of 80's high quality audio from DAC's was just at the beginning of popularity, 5 years later at the beginning of 90's this was quite common knowledge and this know how is visible in Amiga circuitry evolution. |
||
29 June 2024, 09:50 | #28 |
Registered User
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: Italy
Age: 49
Posts: 2,949
|
Paula rulez !
|
29 June 2024, 09:53 | #29 |
AKA Mr. Rhythm Master/AIS
Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: London, UK
Posts: 106
|
|
30 June 2024, 14:00 | #30 | |
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: PL?
Posts: 2,888
|
Quote:
And important remark - this knowledge evolved in decades - i bet if in 1984 such knowledge exist with same level of "popularity" as today then overall audio circuitry will be better since first design - CD32 is last Amiga, also it was designed with at least cooperation with application engineers dedicated to CD audio DAC implementation so such knowledge propagate down to Paula circuitry. Some topic is currently going on this how much A600 can be improved: https://eab.abime.net/showthread.php?t=86880 also this thread can be interesting: https://eab.abime.net/showthread.php?t=109051 It can be nice to see if someone offer those retro PCB's for various projects with changes addressing all those small things - this not ruin legacy heritage of Paula... |
|
30 June 2024, 17:24 | #31 | |
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Norway
Posts: 1,719
|
Quote:
Every other Amiga has a fixed low-pass whose cutoff is around 4-5kHz (depending on model). It really does remove the high fidelity from the sound. |
|
30 June 2024, 18:00 | #32 | |
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: germany
Posts: 440
|
Quote:
But the issue that's responsible for most variations between SID chips is filter variation; AFAIR they use a FET on the chip as a voltage-controlled resistor (voltage provided by a DAC, ofc), and that method is very sensitive to manufacturing tolerances and even operating temperature. If one disables the filter, SIDs sound more similar across different revisions. They also fixed that behavior with the 8580... |
|
Yesterday, 03:06 | #33 | |
Registered User
Join Date: May 2023
Location: essex
Posts: 512
|
Quote:
To be fair, after adjusting the volume control on a TV/monitor you're not going to hear much difference really, or even a budget midi-hifi etc, stuff you would only notice on a decent amp and decent large hi-fi speakers I suspect. My friend had an A500 with a slightly better Kenwood hifi with proper Dolby Pro Logic and better speakers etc than mine and I couldn't really tell the difference from my machine using a slightly less sophisticated Pioneer at home 10 minutes drive away. Probably have to test them side by side Would be interesting to compare 1000/2000/3000/4000 as these were expensive machines. The 1000 motherboard has a lot going on with the most components and that riser to the daughterboard. |
|
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
Thread Tools | |
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Giana Sisters audio quality | PDrill | support.Games | 0 | 23 October 2023 19:38 |
CD32 Audio CD has better sound quality than a standard CD player ? | Rochabian | support.Hardware | 6 | 20 September 2023 08:02 |
What do you think was the most sophisticated/technically impressive Amiga flight sim? | vroom6sri | Nostalgia & memories | 63 | 29 September 2019 14:33 |
alone in the dark cd32 technically possible ? | turrican3 | Retrogaming General Discussion | 3 | 02 June 2018 03:34 |
High Quality reproduction of Audio on 8 bit. | pandy71 | Amiga scene | 0 | 01 July 2013 15:08 |
|
|