English Amiga Board

English Amiga Board (https://eab.abime.net/index.php)
-   Amiga scene (https://eab.abime.net/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Got sued for an AMIGA game made with BACKBONE in 2015! (https://eab.abime.net/showthread.php?t=76750)

paul1981 23 January 2015 19:05

Up to 50 downloads and zero profit for you, minuscule to zero exposure to Amiga fans (zero to general public!).... I just don't see how they could prove any loss of earnings.... I have difficulty taking this seriously because of that. It's their job to do this but in your case there has been no loss to Studio Payo and so no claim can be made.
Make it clear that further correspondence from yourself will be charged at £10,000 per letter. :)

As for the €500 crap, I hope you're not thinking of paying it? And besides, emails don't count in this case because there's no guarantee you'd check it or it wouldn't end up in spam or something.

pandy71 23 January 2015 19:12

Go to lawyer and contact with rights owner (after lawyer consultancy) - i believe that all doubts should be on your side and i believe that you was not aware of braking/violating any law and as you removed game then you showed a good will. For sure you should not pay anything without aligning with your lawyer.

Don't bother - you have 5 days from moment when you read message but once again - ask lawyer (and as Swedish citizen only Swedish law apply in your case).

paul1981 23 January 2015 19:13

I wouldn't think that a member on here reported you, seriously. IMHO I'd say they found your game all by themselves as they're payed to do so.

ma693541 23 January 2015 19:14

Do you old folk's like me remember the unofficial Smurf CD's with the voices in the song's on a high pitch, like the Smurf Macarena and so on? I have one of them and there was atleast made a thrilogy of them. I have never heard that the producer behind them got sued and this was a cd given out at the -90ths.

Don't be stupid hipoonios to sign anything or pay the money they sue you for, let a lawyer help you out here. Pity a company like Studio Peyo sue someone and not being flattered by someone making a game for a computer as that old. Shame on them.

Im sure many here have Facebook, so we should have made a page like 'Boycott Studio Peyo' and the reason why, because they sue a nice guy who have made a game for a computer there the hardware is 30 year's old.

Retro1234 23 January 2015 19:15

Return to sender
Dont live here

: Also whats wrong with backbone slideshow?

supaduper 23 January 2015 19:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by ma693541 (Post 999379)
do you old folk's like me remember the unofficial smurf cd's with the voices in the song's on a high pitch, like the smurf macarena and so on? I have one of them and there was atleast made a thrilogy of them. I have never heard that the producer behind them got sued and this was a cd given out at the -90ths.

Don't be stupid hipoonios to sign anything or pay the money they sue you for, let a lawyer help you out here. Pity a company like studio peyo sue someone and not being flattered by someone making a game for a computer as that old. Shame on them.

Im sure many here have facebook, so we should have made a page like 'boycott studio peyo' and the reason why, because they sue a nice guy who have made a game for a computer there the hardware is 30 year's old.

+1

Also it says on wiki that the publishing rights are now with: Le Lombard

Paul_s 23 January 2015 19:46

I had a bad feeling when I first saw your game - wish I'd said something at the time.

Smurfs is pretty hot property at the moment (last major film in 2013). I bet no one would have bothered you if The Smurfs franchise hadn't had a revival in the past few years.

Hope you find some resolution to it all. I'd ignore the demands for money - I would hazard a guess they'll probably leave you alone now you've removed the 'offending' material.

Lemming880 23 January 2015 20:02

This is so wrong. I hope you get it solved. Such a shame for losing this game. You've put so much hard work in it. :(

jimbob 23 January 2015 20:04

Hang on, they sent you a demand for legal fees, by email, addressed to Mr Persson, (sic). Sure. take the game down to be on the safe side but otherwise ignore completely, you should not have sent any message in reply.

Or, if you have money to burn. you could sign the letter, send the payment, in cash, all smeared in your best beer shits.

Or if you have nothing more pressing to do, you could make it your lifes mission to be a lot more trouble than you're worth, maybe get yourself a rocket car and a solid gold house out of the whole thing. ;)

Neil79 23 January 2015 20:04

It's now on Reddit!
http://www.reddit.com/r/retrogaming/...y_studio_peyo/

Predseda 23 January 2015 20:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by ma693541 (Post 999379)
Im sure many here have Facebook, so we should have made a page like 'Boycott Studio Peyo' and the reason why, because they sue a nice guy who have made a game for a computer there the hardware is 30 year's old.

I wouldnt do it worse :blased

Mrs Beanbag 23 January 2015 20:19

I'm no lawyer but there are so many things wrong with this.

It starts with "Cease and desist" but it is not just a cease and desist, they are also demanding money. But i also don't see any sort of summons or court order so legal action hasn't really been taken yet? You can't just write to people demanding money for services you didn't want, as far as i know. In my opinion they are just chancing it. It doesn't look like the proper procedure to me at all.

nobody 23 January 2015 20:20

Who the f..k is studio puyo. Never heard of these lamers, now they got some free publicity which cost more than 500€.

Thorham 23 January 2015 20:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by nobody (Post 999410)
Who the f..k is studio puyo.

Studio Peyo, from the Smurfs.

gazj82 23 January 2015 20:29

I would say until this has been through a court they have no right in demanding any sum's of money owed!

Otherwise they could just make up any figure (like they have). It is up to them to prove you guilty of a crime through the normal legal system before they can demand any type of damages.

Not sure where you or they are from but if that's across borders it's unlikely they would pursue that route. I would personally send them a letter explaining the circumstances if they still play silly buggers ignore them after that.

nobody 23 January 2015 20:30

I will call them Puyo, I hope they don't ask me money with e-mails for this.

aysel 23 January 2015 20:31

Whilst they may be acting on behalf of the copyright holder this is nothing more than a simple begging letter. They can not instruct or demand that you pay anything, the only person who can do that is a judge upon issuing a court order.

They will never EVER take you to court, for exactly the same reason that companies who issue parking tickets never ever take anyone to court... because they can not demonstrate in a million years that the ACTUAL losses they have endured are proportionate to the amount of money they are asking for in their begging letter.

These are exactly the same as the companies/fraudsters who get a list of 20000 IP addresses and bang out letters to people who download films on PirateBay... ''Pay £500 and we will not take you to court''. Again, no one has EVER been taken to court.. they don't need to take anyone to court, they base their entire operating costs to make profit on 5% of the people just shitting themselves and just paying up straight away.... the 95% who throw the letter in the bin will never be contacted again.

Just finally, copyright infringement of this type would not be dealt with through a criminal prosecution, its a civil litigation matter... ideally just like parking tickets you shouldn't have replied and they would just move on... unfortunately they now know they have a 'live one'

Paul_s 23 January 2015 20:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by nobody (Post 999415)
I will call them Puyo, I hope they don't ask me money with e-mails for this.

You've posted twice in this thread about it so please send me 1000 euros in a brown envelope ;)

gazj82 23 January 2015 20:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by aysel (Post 999416)
Whilst they may be acting on behalf of the copyright holder this is nothing more than a simple begging letter. They can not instruct or demand that you pay anything, the only person who can do that is a judge upon issuing a court order.

They will never EVER take you to court, for exactly the same reason that companies who issue parking tickets never ever take anyone to court... because they can not demonstrate in a million years that the ACTUAL losses they have endured are proportionate to the amount of money they are asking for in their begging letter.

These are exactly the same as the companies/fraudsters who get a list of 20000 IP addresses and bang out letters to people who download films on PirateBay... ''Pay £500 and we will not take you to court''. Again, no one has EVER been taken to court.. they don't need to take anyone to court, they base their entire operating costs to make profit on 5% of the people just shitting themselves and just paying up straight away.... the 95% who throw the letter in the bin will never be contacted again.

I think you have just said what I was trying to say but a lot better :)

nobody 23 January 2015 20:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul_s (Post 999417)
You've posted twice in this thread about it so please send me 1000 euros in a brown envelope ;)

OK then. Send me an e-mail.


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 07:11.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.

Page generated in 0.06594 seconds with 10 queries