Autofire: Prohibited or Allowed?

[john4p]

It's not yet specified in the rules. I admit I used autofire for X-Out and Turrican.

I don't feel that's cheating (every joystick I had had an autofire-button or -switch).

But it should be definitely made clear in the rules if it's allowed or not.

What do you think?

[TCD]

Allow autofire! Some games (like X-Out) aren't really playable without it

[humble worm]

I think it should be allowed...
btw sorry for lame question but does winuae have autofires (cannot check it right now)? playing x-out on keyboard is torture, much pain no gain. my left hand begs for relief

[s2325]

In Turrican it's little harder to use secondary weapon with autofire on

[TCD]

Originally Posted by humble worm

btw sorry for lame question but does winuae have autofires (cannot check it right now)? playing x-out on keyboard is torture, much pain no gain. my left hand begs for relief

Yes it has. Look at the screenshot in the attachment

[john4p]

Originally Posted by s2325

In Turrican it's little harder to use secondary weapon with autofire on

That's why I have also single fire assigned to another button. My Dualshock-Layout for Turrican:

/\ - single fire (=> beam)
[] - autofie
X - jump
O - 2nd fire button (or SPACE)
R1 - ALT (=> grenades in Turrican I)

[CHook/OTT]

I don't use AF and X-Out on a PS2 pad bloody kills my thumb after a couple of goes

[Graham Humphrey]

Here's what I wrote on the equivalent Lemon thread for those too lazy to check:

Originally Posted by Me on Lemon Amiga

No, autofire never ever occured to me when I put the rules together for the old EAB League so I guess I take a lot of responsibility for overlooking it.

I suppose we could look at it on a game-by-game basis - i.e. you mentioned Datastorm, obviously if autofire is a power-up then you wouldn't be allowed to use autofire "normally" as it were. Or maybe to make it fair, you can only use autofire in emulation to the same extent you can use it on a real machine, so John's Turrican control layout on the EAB thread would be out, but standard autofire (i.e. like some Amiga joysticks have) would be legal.

Dunno.

[TCD]

Okay, let's sum it up :

Autofire is available as a power-up : Prohibited
Autofire not available : Allowed

What I find quite interesting is that john control layout is not allowed if I got it right

[Graham Humphrey]

Can I just say I'm only throwing ideas about at the moment, don't take what I wrote as gospel...

[TCD]

Originally Posted by Graham Humphrey

Can I just say I'm only throwing ideas about at the moment, don't take what I wrote as gospel...

If not you, who else can give us enlightment?
Maybe you and Biscuit should talk about it

[john4p]

Here's what I wrote on the equivalent Lemon thread:

Originally Posted by john4p

Back when I had an Amiga 500 I had a competition pro joystick that had a standard firebutton and a triangular shaped autofire-button (which only fired when you pressed it).

So I protest against forbidding my control layout!

[TCD]

Can someone finally give me a damn linkie to the 'equivalent Lemon thread'?

[john4p]

Okay...

http://www.lemonamiga.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5643

[TCD]

Cheers john Quite interesting discussion. I think the 'auto-fire is allowed as long as there's no auto-fire upgrade' is a good way to deal with it

[Zetr0]

Although I am yet to compete in the Games, I feel moved to say that there is no way to police / marshal such a ruling.

from this I would say that autofire should be allowed, even if you believe its a form of cheating.

The only thing would be to consider rules for games that could allow you to Score Farm, (i.e. sit back and blast it up to a high score without doing anything) but this comes down to another type of Game Exploitation.

its a tricky road to travel, my hope is that everyone whom competes is competing for the sake of the game and not the title of high scorer at any cost.

but in the spirit of the Games....


Press Fire to Play

[Graham Humphrey]

Originally Posted by Zetr0

Although I am yet to compete in the Games, I feel moved to say that there is no way to police / marshal such a ruling.

Yep, true, same as any other rule we enforce really, we just trust that people stick by the rules we set. Without that the whole thing would fall apart.