Dune 1 - WhdLoad Problem

Thalion · 05 September 2016, 21:18

Hi

http://eab.abime.net/showthread.php?...01#post1109701

if you have a look at this thread you can see that there is some issue with the Dune 1 install. Maybe someone can have a look at it? Would be very cool if this could be fixed.

Thanks

kriz · 10 April 2017, 03:27

I also get problems with the Dune Whdload 2.5, crash when saving, but not every time... Getting exception access fault .. Will try more options aswell later.. System: OS39 latest whdload 18.3 and 060, preload ..

jotd · 10 April 2017, 10:06

you have to be more specific (access fault isn't going to cut it) and why don't you create a bug on mantis? http://mantis.whdload.de/

If you check the activity you'll see that it's not just a dead end, specially if your report is well documented, with crash log, details on how to reproduce...

in the case of Dune, there are several versions (at least 4), and for instance French version crashes if you leave the intro running, whereas other versions don't have this problem.

So specify the version where the crash occurs.

kriz · 10 April 2017, 15:47

Hi. Yes will do a full bugreport later today, played without -preload setting some more yesterday and no problems saving (atleast till now).. Thx for thew fast answer jotd !!

tolkien · 25 December 2017, 23:39

I'm trying the spanish version in a cd32 with fastram and CF and have the error "whdload function resload_diskload called unacceptable argument" when I try to save or load.
In my 1260 seems to go good with nocache and now even without it.
I can upload the files to the zone if somebody want to look for it.
Thanks.

jotd · 26 December 2017, 10:04

that is interesting if you can post the message. Or upload in the zone, but I suspect that in that case a whole savedisk (disk.4) is missing which explains the error.

those random bugs are very hard to fix, plus games has 4+ versions and a lot of self-modifying code, which partly explains why it hasn't been fixed yet. Sometimes I regret not to have created a proper file version (relying on the original disk to file extractor or not) which would have avoided disk access which seems to be a nuisance in this game.

kikems · 26 December 2017, 10:33

I use the spanish Dune 1 form retrowiki.es forum and it works when save with my AmigaOS3.5 on my Vampire A600.
I'd use Estrayk link for WBHDload, you can find in this thread for test.
http://www.retrowiki.es/viewtopic.php?f=24&t=813

tolkien · 26 December 2017, 14:16

@kikems I use that version and is ok in my a1200 but fails in the cd32.

@jotd Disk.4 is there. I have tried with Savepath=ram: and it works. Perhaps is a filesystem error? I'll put the exact error later tonight.

dlfrsilver · 26 December 2017, 14:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by jotd

that is interesting if you can post the message. Or upload in the zone, but I suspect that in that case a whole savedisk (disk.4) is missing which explains the error.

those random bugs are very hard to fix, plus games has 4+ versions and a lot of self-modifying code, which partly explains why it hasn't been fixed yet. Sometimes I regret not to have created a proper file version (relying on the original disk to file extractor or not) which would have avoided disk access which seems to be a nuisance in this game.

Yes, relying the extracted files is the way to go, it loads faster, etc....

What is the problem with this ?

jotd · 26 December 2017, 16:28

the problem is creating an installation, since the disks are NDOS, and do not contain apparent files. They're extracted using the (shitty) custom HD installer which is difficultly integrable in a clean "installer" script.

dlfrsilver · 26 December 2017, 17:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by jotd

the problem is creating an installation, since the disks are NDOS, and do not contain apparent files. They're extracted using the (shitty) custom HD installer which is difficultly integrable in a clean "installer" script.

You need to use RAWDIC to do that. Ask eventually a hand to Stingray for that

jotd · 26 December 2017, 21:17

you really think I don't know how to extract files from a trackloader diskimage? It's just that I didn't take the time to do it. I'm not asking Stingray to do my work.

I just don't to spend 8 hours doing something when the program already works / can be fixed. On this report, some say it's working some say it doesn't.

history from 2014 (last release):

- fixed crash after save in the french version when clicking on the planet
(warning: french version still has the intro bug, see notes below)

so AFAIK there's no other issue (the other thread ends with "copied the disk.4, seems to be ok")

So yes, quitting by powering off the amiga after saving may not save. You have to quit whdload. That's not a specific issue. Are there any users with issues? @tolkien waiting for your report & files.

tolkien · 26 December 2017, 21:32

The thing is that It can only reproduced in the CD32 setup but this is the error.

Function 'resload_Diskload' called unacceptable arguments
$FEAF9E00 PC=$9FB8EA (Slave $3E2)

The game is in the zone.

StingRay · 27 December 2017, 09:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by jotd

but I suspect that in that case a whole savedisk (disk.4) is missing which explains the error.

Missing save disk doesn't produce this error, WHDLoad would complain about a missing file in this case. It must be something else.

Quote:

Sometimes I regret not to have created a proper file version (relying on the original disk to file extractor or not) which would have avoided disk access which seems to be a nuisance in this game.

Out of interest I checked the original installer and quickly created a RawDIC imager which saves all files (DOS files and "hidden" NDOS files). I'll attach the binary and source to this message so you can use it if you want.

jotd · 27 December 2017, 12:20

I'll certainly use that to create a new version of the install since it's already created. I'll create an install script which proposes both versions. Thanks.

StingRay · 27 December 2017, 13:31

My pleasure.

While checking the different versions of the game I have noticed there are 3 files which have a different name depending on the language. I have updated the imager to support this and tested it with all 4 available SPS versions. I believe there is at least one more version of the game as the "ID" numbers are 1,2,3,5. 4 is missing and I guess that's a version with a different language.

Anyway, updated imager and source attached.

Retroplay · 27 December 2017, 13:49

Spanish DIC images zoned.

StingRay · 27 December 2017, 16:19

Thanks Retro. Spanish version has ID 6 and I updated the imager to support it. ID 4 is still missing so I suppose there are at least 6 different versions of the game.

daxb · 27 December 2017, 17:35

Now someone have to come with a version that has ID 7.

Sorry.

jotd · 03 January 2018, 18:16

@Stingray I tested your extractor and it works but some files are corrupt / not with the proper name.

I have zoned the install I did with the original install (what a shitty program it is, making you change disks 10 times) + your files (french version)

Some files are clearly corrupt (cygnus temp ... strings) instead of what appears to be packed data

file dir.0 is named dir.1 for instance (fortunately: allowed me to detect that the files you created are corrupt)

05 September 2016, 21:18	#1
Thalion Amiga Collector Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Germany Age: 41 Posts: 679	Dune 1 - WhdLoad Problem Hi http://eab.abime.net/showthread.php?...01#post1109701 if you have a look at this thread you can see that there is some issue with the Dune 1 install. Maybe someone can have a look at it? Would be very cool if this could be fixed. Thanks

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Dune	Anding	request.Old Rare Games	25	04 July 2022 16:02
dune 2 help!	Mac 1000	New to Emulation or Amiga scene	10	31 March 2016 22:32
Dune	hardsequencer	Retrogaming General Discussion	9	29 November 2013 15:41
Dune - old file-based WHDLoad patch	MethodGit	request.Old Rare Games	18	08 April 2007 14:26
How to install Dune II?	Smoma	New to Emulation or Amiga scene	8	17 January 2006 22:15

10 April 2017, 03:27	#2
kriz Junior Member Join Date: Sep 2001 Location: No(R)Way Age: 41 Posts: 3,185	I also get problems with the Dune Whdload 2.5, crash when saving, but not every time... Getting exception access fault .. Will try more options aswell later.. System: OS39 latest whdload 18.3 and 060, preload ..

10 April 2017, 10:06	#3
jotd This cat is no more Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: FRANCE Age: 52 Posts: 8,160	you have to be more specific (access fault isn't going to cut it) and why don't you create a bug on mantis? http://mantis.whdload.de/ If you check the activity you'll see that it's not just a dead end, specially if your report is well documented, with crash log, details on how to reproduce... in the case of Dune, there are several versions (at least 4), and for instance French version crashes if you leave the intro running, whereas other versions don't have this problem. So specify the version where the crash occurs.

10 April 2017, 15:47	#4
kriz Junior Member Join Date: Sep 2001 Location: No(R)Way Age: 41 Posts: 3,185	Hi. Yes will do a full bugreport later today, played without -preload setting some more yesterday and no problems saving (atleast till now).. Thx for thew fast answer jotd !!

25 December 2017, 23:39	#5
tolkien AmigaMan Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: Castro Urdiales/Spain Posts: 760	I'm trying the spanish version in a cd32 with fastram and CF and have the error "whdload function resload_diskload called unacceptable argument" when I try to save or load. In my 1260 seems to go good with nocache and now even without it. I can upload the files to the zone if somebody want to look for it. Thanks.

26 December 2017, 10:04	#6
jotd This cat is no more Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: FRANCE Age: 52 Posts: 8,160	that is interesting if you can post the message. Or upload in the zone, but I suspect that in that case a whole savedisk (disk.4) is missing which explains the error. those random bugs are very hard to fix, plus games has 4+ versions and a lot of self-modifying code, which partly explains why it hasn't been fixed yet. Sometimes I regret not to have created a proper file version (relying on the original disk to file extractor or not) which would have avoided disk access which seems to be a nuisance in this game.

26 December 2017, 10:33	#7
kikems Registered User Join Date: Jun 2016 Location: Oviedo Posts: 357	I use the spanish Dune 1 form retrowiki.es forum and it works when save with my AmigaOS3.5 on my Vampire A600. I'd use Estrayk link for WBHDload, you can find in this thread for test. http://www.retrowiki.es/viewtopic.php?f=24&t=813

26 December 2017, 14:16	#8
tolkien AmigaMan Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: Castro Urdiales/Spain Posts: 760	@kikems I use that version and is ok in my a1200 but fails in the cd32. @jotd Disk.4 is there. I have tried with Savepath=ram: and it works. Perhaps is a filesystem error? I'll put the exact error later tonight.

26 December 2017, 16:28	#10
jotd This cat is no more Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: FRANCE Age: 52 Posts: 8,160	the problem is creating an installation, since the disks are NDOS, and do not contain apparent files. They're extracted using the (shitty) custom HD installer which is difficultly integrable in a clean "installer" script.

26 December 2017, 21:17	#12
jotd This cat is no more Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: FRANCE Age: 52 Posts: 8,160	you really think I don't know how to extract files from a trackloader diskimage? It's just that I didn't take the time to do it. I'm not asking Stingray to do my work. I just don't to spend 8 hours doing something when the program already works / can be fixed. On this report, some say it's working some say it doesn't. history from 2014 (last release): - fixed crash after save in the french version when clicking on the planet (warning: french version still has the intro bug, see notes below) so AFAIK there's no other issue (the other thread ends with "copied the disk.4, seems to be ok") So yes, quitting by powering off the amiga after saving may not save. You have to quit whdload. That's not a specific issue. Are there any users with issues? @tolkien waiting for your report & files.

26 December 2017, 21:32	#13
tolkien AmigaMan Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: Castro Urdiales/Spain Posts: 760	The thing is that It can only reproduced in the CD32 setup but this is the error. Function 'resload_Diskload' called unacceptable arguments $FEAF9E00 PC=$9FB8EA (Slave $3E2) The game is in the zone.

27 December 2017, 12:20	#15
jotd This cat is no more Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: FRANCE Age: 52 Posts: 8,160	I'll certainly use that to create a new version of the install since it's already created. I'll create an install script which proposes both versions. Thanks.

27 December 2017, 13:49	#17
Retroplay Lemon Curry ? Join Date: Sep 2004 Location: Denmark Age: 49 Posts: 4,079	Spanish DIC images zoned.

27 December 2017, 16:19	#18
StingRay move.l #$c0ff33,throat Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: Berlin/Joymoney Posts: 6,863	Thanks Retro. Spanish version has ID 6 and I updated the imager to support it. ID 4 is still missing so I suppose there are at least 6 different versions of the game.

27 December 2017, 17:35	#19
daxb Registered User Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Germany Posts: 3,303	Now someone have to come with a version that has ID 7. Sorry.

03 January 2018, 18:16	#20
jotd This cat is no more Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: FRANCE Age: 52 Posts: 8,160	@Stingray I tested your extractor and it works but some files are corrupt / not with the proper name. I have zoned the install I did with the original install (what a shitty program it is, making you change disks 10 times) + your files (french version) Some files are clearly corrupt (cygnus temp ... strings) instead of what appears to be packed data file dir.0 is named dir.1 for instance (fortunately: allowed me to detect that the files you created are corrupt)

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)