I didn't get a PC till 1998, so I have pretty much lived through Amiga from start to end, but going back through a few games, I would have to say Syndicate looked interesting on the PC with the animated menus and High res graphics, but it has one problem, the colours look crap in game, you know what I mean, the checkerboarding colours.
But anyway, Doom didn't bother me, I just played it on my Amiga instead