I voted 7. I like some elements of the game (music, leveldesign, triggers / traps, ideas like frozen river), I dislike some (dialogues, bad collision detection vs environment, strange levels choosing) and I considers other acceptable (graphics, game controls). So in my opinion 7 is okay.
Please others - vote for the game too:
http://www.lemonamiga.com/games/details.php?id=4305 - positive or negative, to have some wide overview.