I play a lot of games. However, I find that I am spending time with my Amiga (real or emulated) less and less.
When the mood stikes me, though, I fire up a game of Pirates! (all-time fave, Amiga version is the best bar-none) or sometimes Cannon Fodder or Walker.
I think part of the problem for me is having to muck around with the settings in WinUAE for a few minutes in order to get some of my "untried" games to work.
I just think that it sucks to put so much effort into getting a game to run, just to find that it awful.