Originally Posted by TheCyberDruid
If there was one game I thought that nobody would have on their overrated list, it would be Monkey Island... Guess there was to be a connection between that and the love for Craptive somewhere
Actually, Monkey Island was (imo) underrated in one instance. It scored a 79% from "Det Svenska Datormagazin" (abbreviated to DMZ). The same magazine also scored Rise of the Dragon a 96%, and Dark Seed got the same score as Monkey.
At least they rectified it by giving the sequel a 98%. Their highest scoring game was Civilization, which got a 99%.