Yes, I certainly have that issue. With such an overabundance of games, and with even more titles available with a click of the mouse, I sometimes feel swamped and overwhelmed.
And that's just trying to play and experience the (long list of) titles that I like, let alone attempting to complete them.
It was better when I was a kid, and my focus was aimed at a couple of games at a time, purely because I didn't have that many games, and I never knew when the next new game would arrive. I would even concentrate on titles that I didn't particularly like, just because it was there and there were no other titles to snare my interest away. In doing so, I'd develop a love for games I'd originally dismissed.
I also have the same issue with PC games at the present moment. My hard drives are loaded and nearing saturation point.