ok, some games I think that are overrated:
- Turrican Series (what is all about the hype? Music is great, but I don't really get much fun)
- F 16 Falcon (hey, I am an Interceptor-Pilot!)
- Speedball 2 (I do like the first one more)
- Monkey Island 2 (I loved the first one, but the 2nd wasn't as much fun)
- Bundesliga Manager Hattrick (way too complicated)
and some others I don't remember atm.
Just to make it clear: I don't think (and say) that the above games are CRAP! I just would have given a lower ranking.