SOTB was one of the games that really blew me away when I first saw it on my new Amiga but the fact I didnt play it for very long says it all.
I used to load it up regularly (still do) just for the music which is amazingly atmospheric and haunting.
Turbo made a good point that nothing impresses anymore. I think if someone showed me a game with actual photo realistic graphics I wouldnt be amazed as I was back when I first saw Beast.
Even if they remade it it would have very little to do with the original anyway except in name.