Ok, let's wrap this up shall we?
Good games are good games, but there are some people that don't like them but don't call them bad. That's just plain wrong.
Objectivity and subjectivity lives hand in hand in games (a game can be good in an objective way, but wether you like it or not is subjective).
Chaos Engine is a brilliant game that you either like or don't. And it's not a clone. It's an action game.
Gauntlet is a brilliant game that you either like or don't (but not on the amiga?).
And this my friends... is a wrap up. Now let's continue listing all those superb games that you don't like, and some crap ones too that nobody liked but the press.