I think SWOS is the best Sensible Soccer game (As everyone else, I think), and I hardly used the career mode, which I thought to be a complete waste of time.
So, can I compare it to Kick Off 2?
Except the ones in the poll, I think the best soccer games on Amiga are Goal!, Manchester United: The Double and Lothar Mathaaus Soccer (Also known as European Champions and a dozen more of different titles), which makes me believe I like more or less the same kind of games that Stareye likes
European Champions is very underrated IMO.
Total Football was fun for a while, until I found there were 2 easy ways to score, and any other way of scoring was extremely difficult. But the graphics were pretty good.