Totally stupid analysis.
In most of his examples he's chosen 2D games that tried to create 3D effects back then - unfair.
Some games only work well in 2D so it will always have it's place in gaming. Super Mario World, Bubble Bobble, bomberman, Biplanes/dogfight etc just won't work or be as playable in 3D.
Gaming is best in 2D AND 3D. A playable game is just that - it doesn't need polygons to be labelled as good.
Yes, I kept my comments short and sweet because his page doesn't deserve any more of my time - I'll just take it as a joke and a bit of fun. he he.