Pirates! or Pirates! Gold? Which one do you prefer?
 

Well? Which version do you think is the best? Pirates! on the Amiga, or Pirates! Gold on the CD32?

To make sure you all remember the difference between each version, check out these:

Pirates!

Pirates! Gold (CD32)

Me? I prefer the original. Better animation (or at least lack of unecessarily huge sprites with terrible animation when swordfighting) and generally nicer graphics and sound. I didn't enjoy the cartoon look as much as the original look.

Port Royale 2 on PC

screenies

Sorry for hijacking your thread but I'm thinking about this game all the time.
Voted for Pirates! ;)

No problem ;)

I'm really looking forward to Port Royale 2 myself. That, and of course the new Pirates! from Sid Meier.

My vote to Pirates!

this looks really good.

oh, pirates! :agree

I remember i got to be King's Advisor with 134 points of 100 or smtnhg. Great game! I will play i through again sometime i'm sure ;)

Oh and i voted for the original Pirates! 'cause it's plain better. :agree

Visit home and check my thread! ;)

Pirates!

yeah I know, there are some really neat screanshots "at home" :xmas

Pirates!, because the graphics and controls are superior.

the graphics are superior? well... hmmm :blased

Well YES. It's minimalistic :) Pirates Gold's graphics are technically advanced, but aren't very nice.

Yup, it's not always about having the most colours or highest resolution. Sometimes pure design is what seperates the graphics.

I mean, I can easily pick out quite a few titles on the amiga that I consider to have better graphics than an average 3D PS2 title.

pirates was good looking and it made me sense at home, well designed and iviting. just i've no really played it. (just maybe 5 minutes?) so it is Sword and Galleons for me

Pirates! is my most played game EVER :D Pirates! Gold was fun for some days but then I turned back to the "Original" anyway :D

where is the option for I'm not a bloody pirate!!!

Pirates! :)

Pirates! Gold is all tainted in pink. Seriously...
:nuts